as I understand it, the scholarship has actually so much not compellingly reply a far-reaching question the the text of *Romeo and Juliet*; namely, why the Capulets and the Montagues are at war. Ns am convinced based upon my understanding of Shakespeare"s poetics the an unmistakably exactly answer is supplied in the text, yet cleverly and discreetly.Please carry out the the next hypotheses that which girlfriend are conscious - your own or scholars" - to the "unmistakably correct answer."

You are watching: Why do the capulets and montagues hate each other


The start prologue just mentions that the feud in between the Capulets and also the Montagues stemmed from a grudge between the 2 families.

In the opened of action 1, we view that even the existence of a Capulet or a Montague deserve to instantaneously begin a fight since of the hatred they felt for each other.

The new mutiny originates from the mystery love affair between Romeo and also Juliet. The irony is that in action 1, the leader of Verona tried come convince lord Capulet and also Lord Montague to end their feud due to the fact that it ongoing to reason disruption by disturbing the tranquility in Verona.

My translate of why i think the feud started is the it is not specifically written, yet it may have been a disagreement or a war in between the families due to the fact that Shakespeare mentions "civil blood." this in turn started a generational feud that finished with the deaths that Romeo and Juliet.

rise • 0 Downvote
add comment

5.0 (91)

Literature instructor, specializing in Shakespeare

check out tutors favor this

See more: 19 Is What Percent Of 76 As A Percentage? 19 Is What Percent Of 76

see tutors favor this

Shakespeare"s plays begin in the middle of points (as all great stories do). We, together the audience, room entering a story that"s currently in the midst of its narration. In the Prologue, we discover that "from old grudge break to brand-new mutiny" (line 3). The feud is old however the fighting has recently damaged out again. We don"t know why. The Prologue also sets increase the fact that these space two family members that are exceptionally similar. They both reside in Verona. They space wealthy and also established families -- "both alike in dignity" even. For all handy purposes, they have to be allies rather than enemies.

The following hint that us get originates from the Prince in action 1 scene 1. The Prince, after breaking up the struggle in action 1 step 1, states: "And listen the sentence that your moved prince./Three civil brawls, bred of one airy word." really recently, three various public fights have broken out among the Capulets and Montagues. The feud in between the two families has end up being public and violent sufficient for the Prince come worry around the safety of his people and also his city.

I would argue that"s component of the tragedy: we don"t know why they room fighting, thus we can"t totally understand what would be at the very root that why Romeo and also Juliet can"t it is in together. Shakespeare to adjust the pat in the warmth of Verona, Italy. The days space long and also hot, thus mirroring the the atmosphere of the citizens. They are physically hot and also they are warm with fury -- small things can collection them off. Much more than anything, Shakespeare is reflecting a harsh irradiate on humanity: Humans host grudges. We host prejudices and hate in our hearts that occasionally can"t also be explained by ourselves. The tragedy the Romeo and also Juliet is that it doesn"t have actually to finish in tragedy, however it does.