As friend seem to have actually noticed, in the “Humpty Dumpty” nursery rhyme, i do not have anything does it say that Humpty is an egg, yet he is frequently presented thus in pictures and also stories. The version of the rhyme that most children learn today goes prefer this:

Humpty Dumpty satellite on a wall,Humpty Dumpty had actually a great fall.All the king horses and also all the king menCouldn’t put Humpty with each other again.

You are watching: Why did humpty dumpty have a great fall

The an initial known publishing of Humpty Dumpty was contained in youth Amusements by Samuel Arnold in 1797. In the version, the last lines review “Fourscore men and fourscore an ext / could not do Humpty Dumpty wherein he to be before.” over the next century, the rhyme appeared in numerous publications with sport on the lyrics.

These publication did not incorporate the very first use of the term “humpty dumpty,” though. According to the Oxford English Dictionary, “humpty dumpty” was first used in the 17th century and referred to brandy boiled with ale. In the 1700s, it was additionally a term supplied to define a short, clumsy person. It has additionally been a nickname attributed to someone who has had actually too much alcohol (perhaps imbibing the drink of the same name).

As the well-known nursery happiness is no a bottle of alcohol no one a person, it is most most likely that the nursery rhyme was intended together a riddle. The answer come the riddle, that course, is “an egg”—something that, if the rolled off a wall, can not it is in mended by any number of people. Today, the answer is so well known that the character of Humpty Dumpty has actually taken ~ above the figure of an egg and the happiness is not thought about to be a riddle in ~ all, however a story.

Because that this switch from “riddle” come “story”, many world today think that over there is more definition to the nursery rhyme 보다 is provided in the lyrics. Perhaps, in this instance, we can take advice from Humpty Dumpty himself, as watched in v the spring Glass through Lewis Carroll: “When I use a word, it method just what I pick it to mean—neither an ext nor less.” human being will constantly attribute more an interpretation to nursery rhymes 보다 was originally intended.

Nursery rhymes are typically linked to historic events, however it is daunting to prove that imagery in the nursery rhymes represents historic places and also figures. Most modern rhymes, after all, are produced with the will of being silly, repetitive, and also enjoyable for children to repeat fairly than for their historical significance (think “Miss mary Mack” and also other clapping games).

Two that the most renowned theories attach Humpty Dumpty to two separate historical events. The an initial is the autumn of Colchester. During the English Civil battle in 1648, the town of Colchester was under siege. Supposedly, a male named Jack Thompson was stationed on the walls v a cannon nicknamed “Humpty Dumpty.” Thompson and also the cannon regulated to execute a lot of damages to the progressing Parliamentarian troops, until the cannon eventually tumbled to the ground. Provided the size and also weight the the cannon, the dozens of guys who attempted come lift it back to its ar on the wall surface were can not to carry out so. Eventually, Colchester was required to open up its gates and also surrender. If the siege the Colchester walk happen, it is unlikely that Humpty Dumpty refers to anything in the siege as it occurred over a century prior to Humpty Dumpty to be recorded and there is no recorded connection between the two.

The other renowned theory is the Humpty Dumpty stood for King Richard III. , referred to as the “humpbacked king”. (He supposedly to be a hunchback, though recent proof seems to show Shakespeare was wildly exaggerating ~ above this point, through Richard in reality apparently having scoliosis which do his best shoulder higher than the left, but otherwise no hunch). In 1485, Richard III dealt with at the battle of Bosworth. In this “humpty dumpty” beginning story, it was stated that one of two people his steed was named “Wall” or his men, that abandoned him, were representative the the “wall.” one of two people way, the king dropped off his horse and also was supposedly hacked to pieces on the field—thus no one could put him with each other again. Several troubles exist v this theory, the least of i beg your pardon being that the term “humpbacked” didn’t exist in King Richard’s day, nor for several centuries after. (The ax “hunchback” also didn’t first pop up until the 18th century). Much more importantly was that the king’s continues to be were recently discovered largely undamaged save because that a bludgeon come the head which probably killed him. Additionally, other than pure speculation, as in the ahead “siege that Colchester” theory, no heavy historical proof has been uncovered that reflects that King Richard III to be the impetus for Humpty Dumpty. And, indeed, one of the reasons it’s so regularly connected, due to the fact that of the “all the king’s horses and also all the king’s men” bit, together noted, wasn’t also in the original version, gift the more generic “fourscore men and fourscore more”.

See more: Lego Marvel Superheroes Wii U Cheats & Codes For Wii U (Wiiu)

The historical events that have been attached to “Humpty Dumpty” provide excellent stories, however are based upon pure speculation. Provided the actual evidence at hand, that is far an ext likely the Humpty Dumpty was not intended to be a story, yet rather just a riddle make to children for your amusement. The answer to the riddle, together stated, is “an egg”, i m sorry is why Humpty Dumpty this particular day is practically always depicted as such.

If you favored this article, friend might likewise enjoy our brand-new popular podcast, The BrainFood display (iTunes, Spotify, Google beat Music, Feed), too as:

Bonus Facts:

There is a claimed “lost” city to the Humpty Dumpty rhyme that “proves” the Colchester theory, but it is most likely that was written newly in bespeak to assist with the argument that Humpty Dumpty was a cannon. The guy who gift the brand-new verses would not tell anyone the title of the publication in i m sorry he discovered them nor where the publication could it is in found.Riddles similar to Humpty Dumpty have been recorded in other languages—the French “Boule Boule” and Swedish “Lille Trille” among them.Expand because that References