Arrhenius, Brønsted-Lowry, Lewis… chemists have numerous ways to define and distinguish mountain from bases. Forensic scientists have actually a way all that their very own – how these substances ruin soft tissue, hair, nails, teeth, and bone.1-3 This interest isn’t just around mythbusting TV shows such together Breaking bad, whose protagonists supplied hydrofluoric mountain to dispose the a corpse; it additionally serves a practical purpose in the mindful study of how killers effort to cover your tracks.

You are watching: What happens when an acid dissolves

John Haigh supplied sulfuric mountain to dispose of 6 to nine corpses

The annals the crime are filled with gruesome tales of using chemicals for body disposal. In the mid-to-late 1940s, among England’s most infamous killers, john Haigh, provided sulfuric mountain to dispose at the very least six victims’ corpses – a technique that led to him being referred to as the ‘acid bathtub killer’. The Arellano-Félix Organization, a real-life cartel that influenced a storyline in the 2000 movie Traffic, offered sodium hydroxide to dispose the rivals’ corpses. In 2003, American biochemist Larissa Schuster supplied hydrochloric mountain in a system to eliminate her husband. Many thanks to the occupational of forensic scientists, we can piece together specifically what happened in these attempts to remove a corpse.

Super base

When it comes to soft tissue, select acids and also bases – generally H2SO4, HCl, NaOH, and KOH – wreak destruction via hydrolysis of huge biomolecules (such together proteins, lipids, carbohydrates and nucleic acids), with possible further demolition of smaller units. Alkaline hydrolysis is thought about to have actually the edge end techniques involving acid (and is desired in legitimate animal carcass disposal),* most likely since of the enhanced cleavage of the de defiders bonds the are crucial for the structure integrity the proteins.

This much better cleavage additionally explains why bases malfunction hair and also nails more quickly than acids. Hair is generally composed that keratin proteins, which space packed v the amino mountain cysteine and therefore have comprehensive disulfide bonds. These add to the strength and stability that keratin, and aid to withstand solubilisation by solvents that easily dissolve other proteins. Disufide bonds, however, fall prey come alkaline hydrolysis: hair disappear in minute in bleach or NaOH (something anyone through a blocked sink or shower head knows). Nails are additionally full that keratin; as with hair, researchers have actually observed they are more susceptible to damage by bases 보다 acids.1

Acids at an extremely low pH beat bases when it comes to destroying bone and also teeth,1-5 most likely since of the greater solubility the calcium apatites in acidic conditions. However, devastation of bone in acidic conditions is no rapid job;1-3 at room temperature and also atmospheric pressure, it deserve to take almost a day – or longer, depending upon the mountain – because that bone come dissolve when completely submerged. A team led by Cristina Cattaneo from the college of Milan, Italy, has examined the effect of acid and also base immersion on porcine skeleton macroscopically, microscopically, and also chemically.2-3 They provided differences in appearance (macro- and also microscopically) and the level of damage between acids and also bases offered in their study. Essentially, while acids to a much better job in dissolving bone, highly focused and solid bases quiet cause far-ranging damage. Cattaneo’s group explained the aftermath of using alkaline options on bone in the Journal of Forensic Science thus: ‘At an initial glance, bone showed up structurally intact, yet extremely fragile as complete and immediate crumbling occurred with a straightforward touch’.2 I explain it together feeling similar to, and as easy as, not correct shortbread.

DIY disposal

How perform I know? since I it was observed the process myself, making use of readily easily accessible base and acid offers purchased indigenous a neighborhood DIY store. The base to be pellet lye (NaOH) marketed come clear clogged pipes, when the mountain was muriatic (HCl) used to balance pool pH. Like other researchers, I supplied porcine samples – in this case, pork ribs and pork neck bones. Over a occupational week, ns monitored the destructive processes, note the different appearance that the acidic and basic solutions. Both did a frightening task of degrading the experiment samples – miscellaneous you have the right to see for you yourself in the video clip above.

If my deeds had actually been nefarious, would I have gained away through it? probably not – much like every the perpetrators pointed out earlier. In purchase supplies, i was taped on store security video clip and the store has records of my purchase. Such video or document trails are often revealed throughout investigations, and also are one of the key reasons why chemical disposal research study is performed; if investigators understand whether an mountain or base was used they can inspect who to buy or had access to together chemicals.

Indeed, as soon as employing chemistry to destroy a corpse, the is most likely that just partial devastation will occur. Even with the small samples ns treated over a series of days, there was still staying material accessible for analysis. Together Cattaneo’s team notes: ‘…it is conceivable that a possible attempt come destroy whole body… is a thoroughly different task native destroying small samples.’2

Schuster learned this class the tough way. She put her husband’s human body in a barrel that HCl, and also stored the gruesome container in a warehouse locker. Investigators conveniently located the unit with aid of a witness and also a record trail, and readily established the remains. In 2008 she was sentenced come life there is no parole.

And even if the handle is successful, as in the situation of Haigh, police work have the right to still deal with the crime. Dogged investigators uncovered 28 pounds of person body fat, part of a foot and also a denture on Haigh’s property, ~ which the confessed to the crime. He to be hanged in 1949.

Perhaps Geoffrey Chaucer had it ideal in The Canterbury Tales – murder will certainly out.

*The legit disposal of animal carcasses via alkaline hydrolysis is regularly done in ~ high temperature and also pressure to accelerate the process, which needs speciality apparatus. Together apparatus is not readily easily accessible and that acquisition, or unauthorised use, would raise alarms. Alkaline hydrolysis as an alternate to funeral or cremation of person remains (‘green cremation’) is controversial and not widely available.


1 K M Hartnett, l C Fulginiti, and F Di Modica,J. Forensic Sci., 2011, 56, 954 (DOI:10.1111/j.1556-4029.2011.01752.x)

2 A Amadasiet al,J. Forensic Sci.

See more: 2008 Dodge Avenger Fuse Box Location ? Dodge Avenger (2008

, 2017, DOI: 10.1111/1556-4029.13429

3 A Amadasiet al,Leg. Med. (Tokyo), 2015, 17, 503 (DOI: 10.1016/j.legalmed.2015.10.006)

4 M Cox and S Mays,Human osteology In archaeology and also forensic science, 439, Cambridge college Press, 2000

5 C Dawes,J. Can. Dent. Assoc., 2003, 69, 722(

Raychelle BurksRaychelle Burks is combine professor in chemistry at American University, Washington, DC, US