Here"s a puzzle from Martin Gardner"s collection. It is one old problem, but the technique is tho instructive.

Assume the a full cylindrical can of soda has actually its facility of gravity at the geometric center, fifty percent way up and also right in the middle of the can. Together soda is consumed, the facility of gravity moves lower. As soon as the have the right to is empty, however, the center of heaviness is earlier at the center of the can. Over there must therefore be a suggest at which the facility of heaviness is lowest. To clear your mind that trivial and also uninteresting details, i think the have the right to is a perfect cylinder. Discovering the load of an north can and its weight when filled, how deserve to one recognize what level that soda in one upright have the right to will relocate the facility of gravity of can and also contents come its lowest possible point? come devise a precise problem assume that the empty deserve to weighs 1.5 ounces. It is a perfect cylinder and also any asymmetry presented by punching feet in the peak is disregarded. The can holds 12 ounces (42 gram) the soda, because of this its total weight, once filled, is 13.5 ounces (382 gram). We simply take the height to it is in H, and our outcomes will it is in a portion of H. Answer and discussion.Take the height of the can to be H = 10 units. That is empty weight is m = 1.5 oz. The elevation of fluid in the have the right to is h. The mass of liquid in the full can is M = 12 oz. The formula for elevation of the center of fixed is:

This equation is the weighted median of the an initial moments the the north can, and also its liquid contents. For a cylindrical can, these two masses have their centers of gravity at your centroid, i.e., at H/2 because that the empty can, and h/2 for the liquid v level h. If girlfriend graph the center of mass as a duty of h, you obtain a curve that has actually a minimum at exactly h = 2.5. Center of mass, x,as a function of height of fluid in can, h.The have the right to height is 10 units.
Notice from the graph that as soon as the facility of mass is at its shortest point, that is additionally exactly in ~ the liquid surface. Is this a general result? together the liquid level lowers, the center of massive of the system is at first within the volume the the liquid. Yet the lower it gets, the closer the facility of mass move to the surface ar of the liquid. In ~ some allude it is specifically at the surface ar of the liquid. Together the fluid level lowers more, the facility of mass rises and eventually reaches the center of mass of the deserve to when the have the right to is empty. Once the facility of fixed is exactly at the liquid surface, adding much more liquid will certainly raise the facility of mass, for that liquid goes above the previous center of mass. Yet taking away liquid will likewise raise the facility of mass by remove weight below the previous center of mass. So this is the an essential condition once the center of mass is lowest. Therefore the answer is that the facility of mass is lowest once it is in ~ the same elevation as the surface of the liquid. This is, perhaps, the most profound and also useful fact around this problem, for our debate for the did not count on the form of the can. Thus it additionally applies to containers of any type of shape. However this is probably not the type of answer us wanted. We also want to recognize the place of that crucial point in relation to the elevation of the soda can. Using the notation above, we can equate the moment of liquid and also can.
When x = h we acquire a quadratic equation:
Discard the physically meaningless negative root. This reduce to:
Substituting values, we acquire x = 2.5 for a can of height 10. That is 1/4 the height of the can. That simple fraction is a an outcome of the proportion of the massive of the deserve to to the mass of its components when full. Various other mass ratios do not give basic fractions. Currently (2016) north aluminum 12 oz soda can be ~ weigh about 0.5 ounce (14.7 gram). One wonders whether the human being who designed the problem determined 1.5 oz to make the arithmetic easier. Or probably the problem dates from an previously time when the cans were much more nearly cylindrical and also weighed three times as lot as they do now. V today"s lighter cans, the lowest facility of gravity of the partially filled deserve to is H/6. A prolonged discussion of this deserve to be discovered in Norbert Hermann, The beauty beauty of everyday Mathematics (Springer-Verlag, 2012). A straightforward calculus equipment is likewise included there. That is too lengthy to display here. The calculus solution starts with a basic expression (Eq. 1 above) for the system facility of mass, x, as a role of the lot of fluid in the have the right to (or the elevation of fluid in the can, h. Then collection dx/dh = 0. Settle the quadratic equation to uncover the minimum value of x. This is a lengthy and confusing solution. You may need to use L"Hospital"s rule. These web documents use intuitive approaches. Martin Gardner Physics Stumpers. Trouble #71.


You are watching: Weight of a can of soda


See more: What Is A Zero With A Line Through It, How Can You Tell The Difference Between 0 And O

Donald Simanek, 2017. Return to Physics puzzles.Return come the Donald Simanek"s house page.