The “Battle the English and Mathematics” word trouble has to be making a surname for itself around the web recently. Some people claim the answer is 5, rather 31. In actuality, this trouble has 28 solutions, yet we think the “correct” price is 17.

You are watching: The battle of english and math answer

Skip ahead: reasonable behind the trouble | how to fix the problem | Explaining the answer

vital funds to store the blog going space procured through affiliate partnerships. Some of the web links (ads) ~ above this page incorporate affiliate codes. This walk not affect the article in any other way.

What is The battle of English and Mathematics question?

Although word problems do sometimes gain mistranslated together they happen around, the most frequently quoted “version” the this riddle appears to be the original. This is fortunate together the wording is vital and really specific:

1 Rabbit observed 6 elephants while going to the river.

Every elephant experienced 2 primates going in the direction of the river.

Every monkey stop 1 parrot in your hands.

Q: how many animals are going to the river?

It need to be listed that a difference in between “to” and “toward” walk exist but is irrelevant to the answer, so don’t think around it also hard.

Before relocating on come the next section, try the puzzle yourself and also remember the answer friend get; it will certainly come in comfortable later.

Why are human being saying 5 is the answer?

The factor for getting 5 is likely because of how we think about math problems. Most world went to school at some point in your life, and were usually given quizzes and tests v one correct answer. This is a standard in the field of education, however it leaves part unintended side effects. Namely, farming up in together an setting fosters an expectation that “whenever I’m given a question, I’m intended to find the answer. Once I find response that works, I’m done.” This is not constantly true in the organic world, as some inquiries will have actually multiple answers.

The thinking behind 5, generally goes like this: “1 rabbit saw 6 elephants if going to the river.” just the rabbit was stated to be going to the river, for this reason the elephants should not be. “Every elephant saw 2 primates going come the river.” that didn’t speak every elephant experienced 2 different monkeys, therefore they must have seen the exact same two. “Each monkey holds 1 parrot in your hands. There room 2 monkeys, therefore 2 parrots. 1 hare + 2 primates + 2 parrots = 5 pets total.

It seems logical, right? but remember, that’s based upon the expectation that the inquiry contains “the” answer. If this were a trouble in English alone, that would be true. Nevertheless, the location is ‘The fight of English and Mathematics’. “1 + 2 + 2 = 5” is not the mathematics section of the question, as an easy arithmetic is offered steadily throughout every subject and field that study—just as how the consist of of native alone does not make other an English problem.

Sorry for the interruption, but because I don’t write-up generic ads or sell any type of products…

The only way I keep this website up is through partners favor NordVPN. These males encrypt her data with the same methods used through the NSA, and also I highly recommend their solutions (I wouldn’t companion with lock otherwise.) without a VPN, there is nothing protecting your an individual information such as addresses and search history. If girlfriend don’t already have a VPN organization you enjoy, why not check out what NordVPN has to offer?

How to read the inquiry from both perspectives: English (wording) & mathematics (logic)

Whenever request a inquiry or riddle (unless the is a cheat question), you deserve to expect the all the information needed to fix it is given. This promises the equipment won’t be something favor “there are an ext animals 보다 were mentioned,” or “one that the parrots flew away.” However, this go not median that uncertainties shouldn’t be accounted for. To describe this further, I’ve damaged the riddle right into pieces:

“1 Rabbit experienced 6 elephants when going come the river. “ – we know based on the wording the there is specifically 1 rabbit and that the is going come the river. We understand that over there are specifically 6 elephants. We do not know even if it is or not the elephants are going to the river.

Every elephant observed 2 primates going in the direction of the river.” – We know that every elephant saw exactly 2 monkeys and that all chimpanzees are going to the river. We do no know if the elephants all witnessed the very same monkeys or different monkeys.

Every monkey stop 1 parrot in your hands.” – We know that each monkey is holding exactly 1 parrot. We do not know if the chimpanzees are holding separate parrots, or the very same parrot.

How many pets are going to the river?” – We understand what types of pets there are. We’re do the efforts to fix for the total number of those pets that are going come the river.

This problem is worded come be intentionally deceiving at an initial glance. To find the answer, we need to use language skills—the English section of the problem. However, us are also purposely not offered the total number of animals. To discover the total, we have to use probability—the mathematics section that the question.

We will need to use both English and mathematics to discover the solution.

Finding the actual answer to the English and also Mathematics problem:

If you’ve been reading so far, you might be wondering just how such a question deserve to be solved. Luckily, over there is a “correct” answer! (And no, it’s not “anything” or “there isn’t enough information.” It’s a genuine answer—a nice answer—but the will need a couple of short measures to find.)

You may recognize this form of grid. Possibly you remember it being referred to as a ‘Punnett Square” from biology, as a method to guess certain genotypes? If not, don’t worry. We won’t be looking at any gametes.

As it turns out, this kind of network is really useful for quickly measuring probabilities. Allow me to describe how it works and why on earth I’m making use of it to fix an internet meme.


These grids take every the feasible values because that one change (how countless of a kind of animal could be going come the river), and include them to all the possibilities of one more variable (another animal.) The result is a beloved grid that lists every possible outcome, without us having to find them every one-by-one. This is no the many effective means to carry out this, however certainly simple, and also it it s okay the project done.

Because we have different feasible numbers of parrots, monkeys, or elephants (explained earlier.) We’ll want to number out the many likely variety of total animals. To execute this, we’ll take two groups of animals, parrots and also monkeys, and also plug them right into the grid.

Step one:

How many chimpanzees can over there be? Well, if every elephant watch the exact same two monkeys, that would be 2 monkeys, so that’s our short number. Now, our highest possible number is if every elephant watch two fully different monkeys, and that would be 12 monkeys. Therefore, we have between 2 and 12 primates (all the assorted combinations comprise for the number in between.)

What around parrots? Our lowest is if every monkey holds onto the exact same parrot, 1 (which would certainly be weird, but possible.) Our highest is if we have actually 12 monkeys, and also every monkey holds a different parrot, 12. (There’s one more rule for parrots, however we’ll point out them later to cut earlier on stress.)


I’ve unable to do ahead and plotted the monkeys and parrots. Numbers above the network are feasible parrots, numbers beside the net are feasible monkeys. You have the right to think the the net itself together a battleship game, just instead of letters and numbers, us use two sets of numbers.

If you’re wondering where the black numbers come from, they’re the total variety of animals because that each combination. For example, the outcome of 4 monkeys and also 2 parrots is 4 + 2 = 6. Now, because there is constantly 1 rabbit, us can add 1 come every single square (outcome.) 4 + 2 + 1 is 7. Therefore, if you walk to “4 blue, 2 green” you’ll find a 7.

Step two:

There you have actually it! With simply that one simple square, we’ve calculate every solitary possible mix of parrots, monkeys, and also rabbits! that course, we’re not done yet; we’re forgetting around the elephants (ironic.)

How execute we include elephants to the graph we already made? The price is actually fairly simple. Each of our animals (except rabbits) so much take up 1 dimension each, providing the grid 2 dimensions (x and y if you’re familiar with coordinates.) Therefore, every we have to do is add a third dimension (z) because that the elephants.


You may have noticed the the added dimension turned our square into a cube. Because ‘none of’ or ‘all of’ the elephants could be going to the river, that provides us 0 to 6—our new row. You have the right to think of every elephant as including a “layer” come the cube. Every time girlfriend go ago a layer (up 1 elephant) the total variety of animals (the combination of parrots, monkeys, and rabbits) goes up by 1 elephant.

The way I’ve laid the end the square is so the the smallest number starts at the front-left-bottom (4), and steadily goes up until reaching the back-right-top (31).


Before we tally up our final result, we have to do one much more thing. If you’ll recall, “Every monkey stop 1 parrot in their hands.” return many chimpanzees can organize the very same parrot, one monkey cannot organize multiple parrots. This method the total number of parrots can never exceed that of the monkeys.

To reflect this dominance in ours graph, we simply have to remove every instances wherein the # the parrots is higher than the # the monkeys. The end result is a wedge shape that currently accurately portrays every combination. In ~ this point, all that’s left is to count the “blocks.”

The last answer to The fight of English and Mathematics problem:

Unless otherwise declared (such as by the “rules” of a standardized experimentation system,) unpredictabilities should always be considered as valuable information.

By taking this right into account, the mathematical section of the problem becomes one of basic probability—not simple arithmetic. To find the answer, we’ve compiled a perform of outcomes from 4 animals, come 31.


The higher the bar because that a certain number of animals, the much more outcomes there space that an outcome in the number. Much more outcomes = greater probability.

By taking a look in ~ the graph above, over there is one prize in specific that plainly has a greater probability than any kind of other (winning 8.2% that the time, much greater than the average of 3.6%.) according to this results, the many likely variety of animals going in the direction of the river is 17. 

You’re nearly at the finish of the article,

(We’ve also put with each other some much more information about what a VPN does, if you’re interested)

If i were teaching at a university and gave this question on an test (I wouldn’t—I’m no that cruel), 17 is the prize I would certainly be hoping to see. Climate again, that’s only because I’d mean my college student to study the question in the very same manner ns did. After ~ all, this is mine interpretation together a science educator, vice versa, a mathematician or linguist might expect something totally different. Similar to all points in life, we have the right to only use what us know. My experiences tell me to take into consideration all unpredictabilities in my answer, yet depending on that asks, the “best” answer come give might be 5.

Without inferences, most riddles are unsolvable. Just how you make these inferences will rely heavily on your situation:

If given as a concern on one English test, it would certainly be way to infer the answer is 5.If inquiry on a job questionnaire for data analysis, it may be finest to say 17.If offered as a thoughtful thought experiment, you might say “there deserve to not it is in a decisive answer”…

One price is not enough to refuse the others, yet there is always an advice to “crack the code.” In this manner, riddles such together The battle of English and also Mathematics execute a good job the exposing the large gap between how we right now interpret the world around us, and also what we have the potential however to understand.

Hopefully, you got something from this article

I shot very hard to offer the best quality i can, in every write-up I write, to make the sciences as understandable together possible. Through write-ups like these, i hope to better people’s stays by highlight a curiosity in miscellaneous they might not have otherwise noticed.

See more: How Much Does A Semi Tire Weigh ? How Much Does A Wheel From An 18

If you favor what i do, you can do a lot of to assistance the blog by sharing this short article on locations like Facebook, Twitter, or Pinterest.

If you have any questions, please leave a comment down below and also I’ll get back to girlfriend soon! ~Thank you for reading!

Post navigation