You are watching: In adams fall we sinned all
XVII-XVIII. Revue de la Société d'études anglo-américaines des XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles Année 2010 H-S pp. 65-83
Fait partie d"un numéro thématique : Diffusion de l’écrit dans le monde anglophone. Dispersing the written Word in the English-Speaking human being
Ludwig Sämi. ‘In Adam’s fall / we Sinned All’: Puritan Writing and American Interiority. In: XVII-XVIII. Revue de la société d"études anglo-américaines des XVIIe et XVIIIe siècles. Diffusion de l’écrit dans le monde anglophone. Spreading the composed Word in the English-Speaking World. 2010. Pp. 65-83.
DOI : https://doi.org/10.3406/xvii.2010.2480
See more: How Did Charlemagne Improve The Lives Of People In Europe? ?
RSÉAA XVII-XVIII HS2 (2010) “ IN ADAM’S loss / we SINNED ALL”: PURITAN WRITING and THE make OF AMERICAN INTERIORITY
n “ Sparing the Rod: Discipline and also Fiction in Antebellum America,” Richard Brodhead reports how the renowned Concord educator Bronson alcott made “ his student whip him for their disciplinary infractions” (15). In a clever new historicist analysis of corporeal punishment in the early nineteenth century, Brodhead puts this behavior in a paper definition of Foucauldian interiorized discipline, the
‘ cry indigenous the heart’ that, Foucault argues, started stigmatizing physics punishment in early on modernity together an outrage to ‘ humanity,’ while additionally thereby helping to change the old disciplinary mode with new technologies — much less visible but much more pervasive, much less ‘ cruel’ but more deeply controlling— of modern social regulation. (16)
the associates this through a particular antebellum American perspective of reform in which “ whipping” became associated with “ slavery” (14). Brodhead defines the brand-new kind of force as a “ discipline through love” (18), best exemplified in terms of nurture, together in Horace Bushnell’s
Christian bite (1847). He likewise refers come Lydia Sigourney’s letter to mothers (1839), which he calls “ blueprints because that the construction of superego” (21). Brodhead emphasizes the “ priority the the mommy in nurture” (23), composing that “ the self-control of love reveals itself together a mechanism, in turn, no for mitigation of authority, but really because that the extension of its regulating hold. Once loved parental are appropriately enshrined in the sanctuary of mind, no space is out of your sight” (21). 1
He climate adds further instances of together “ inner policing” (29), among them Horace Mann’s 1844 famous speech come Boston schoolmasters versus corporeal punishment, advocating a much more nurturing concept of education. Brodhead likewise presents examples from antebellum literature, e. G., Hawthorne’s The Scarlet Letter and his monitorings on the pillory
1. The same worry is of course at stake in Ann Douglass’s argument about the “ feminization” that American culture.